Rehabilitation is not the consolation prize
When someone leaves a consultation with a shoulder diagnosis and instructions to do rehabilitation, it is easy to read it as not having been offered the real solution. It is the other way round: in much of shoulder pathology, rehabilitation is the treatment with the best result, and surgery is the alternative for when it is not enough.
Shoulder pain and loss of movement are problems you notice in very concrete ways: not being able to sleep through the night, having to give up sport, or not being able to reach a shelf without pain. The aim of treatment is to get those things back, and the least invasive route to doing so is always the first one considered.
Why it works
The shoulder is the most mobile joint in the body and, in exchange, the one with the least bony stability: it depends almost entirely on muscles and tendons to stay in place. That dependence on soft tissue is its weakness, but also its opportunity, because soft tissue can be trained.
When the rotators and scapular stabilisers regain strength and coordination, the head of the humerus is centred again during movement, the subacromial space recovers and the rubbing stops. Nothing has been touched inside, and the mechanical problem has been solved.
What separates rehabilitation that works
It starts from an accurate diagnosis. The protocol for a frozen shoulder and for instability are almost opposite. Applying the generic one to everyone is the commonest cause of stalling.
It progresses in load. The stimulus has to keep increasing. Repeating the same exercise at the same resistance for months produces no adaptation.
It is measured. Range of movement and strength compared with the healthy side, at the start and periodically. Without measuring there is no way to know whether it is working, and decisions end up being made on impressions.
It has a review date. If there is no objective change at six weeks, the right response is not to persist: it is to revisit the diagnosis.
After surgery
Where surgery is necessary, the rehabilitation that follows determines the result as much as the operation itself. A perfectly reattached tendon in a shoulder that stiffens gives a poor result.
That is why the protocol is agreed before operating and handed over in writing, for the physiotherapist who will do the daily work, whether in Tenerife or anywhere else. Progression is adjusted at the reviews at 2 and 4 weeks.